- Imagine doing something perfectly.
Crazy for You
The penultimate track of Best Coast’s Crazy for You, Each and Every Day, hints at the root of the loneliness that saturates the record. For the eleven preceding numbers we grapple with the angst-ridden lyrical voyage of Bethany Cosentino’s heartbroken solitude; she has lost her love and can’t bear to be without him. Then she sings: “Even through the cheating all I know is that I want you, I wish we could go back to when I was seventeen… and I wouldn’t have been so mean.”
The reveal, that it was our sympathetic protagonist who caused the original rift, is wrapped into the forlorn teen pop word weaving that characterises the whole album. One could write off the lyrical content of Crazy for You as simplistic. Cosentino’s voice could be singing the lines of a diary documenting a lengthy but unrequited obsession, simple and raw, the garbled scribblings of a teenager. Yet it all fits together.
The alternating thrashing and plodding, the lo-fi casette sound of snapping drums and soft distorted guitars, and the pleading words of desperate longing create a nostalgic ode to youth and feeling. That wish to go back in time is realised in form, even if Cosentino doesn’t get her boy back. She doesn’t, of course, at least not within the thirteen songs here. The last track, When I’m with You, is billed as a “bonus track”. It’s an appendix that harks back to better times, before separation. “You and me, we’re just crazy,” she sings, “so when I’m with you I have fun.” Even in recalling happiness, an emotionally distraught declaration waves us off in a beautiful repeating harmony; “I hate sleeping alone.”
Short and brash guitar-heavy pop songs are served up on a platter – the longest track being a second or two over the three minute mark – and a first impression might communicate a teenager-in-a-shed kind of sound. This is not a simple visit to your childhood shed or bedroom though; it is a polished reconstruction by flashback artists. Ali Koehler, former Vivian Girls drummer, and multi-instrumentalist Bobb Bruno provide the noise behind their singer-songwriter leading lady and they match her in understated mood creation.
Every song is about the same thing, that lost love, but it swings between a perfectly cast classic indie pop and honeysuckle moments of faux-fifties balladry (Our Deal) and earnest surf punk (Happy). Lead track Boyfriend delivers a haze of lazy chord bashing, pausing momentarily for a water echo guitar solo that could be one of your friends showing everyone that he can play anything by The Smiths, he just doesn’t want to change his sound settings. Meanwhile, we’re plugged into our story; “I’d love him to the very end, but instead he’s just a friend… I wish he was my boyfriend.”
The variations are not just musically interesting. They are careful accompaniments to the variations of Cosantino’s rich and textured vocal. As she shouts about losing her mind on Each and Every Day, the percussion slaps and rolls and an energetic and deliberate noise strumming penetrates the furore. Then everything breaks down with a soothing bass note reverb, allowing a calmer moment of delirious epiphany behind jingling tambourine. “Everyday day I wake up and thank the stars above, for sending me a man that I could really love.”
Enabled by her band, Cosantino becomes the star of the piece. She writes and sings the lines of an honest loss, revealing a nuanced and thoughtful perusal of love and regret. She shades what some might call an overly simplistic narrative with poignant moments, such as her flash of feminine self-doubt in Boyfriend, singing of how she feels inadequate against her “prettier and skinnier” rival who has a college degree (she dropped out). What might on first glance appear to be a mere summer rock record, is actually a far more consciously crafted work. “I pick up the phone, I want to talk about my day, it really sucked.” It could have been written with candid red lipstick, a series of diary entries infected by the torments of teenage reflection and the lethargy of depression.
This isn’t teen pop as a genre; it’s more like teen pop as subject matter. It is very rare to be able to call a record “genuine” without recoiling at the cliché of that description, but Crazy for You allows it, even encourages it, and most certainly warrants it.